As Hollywood would have it, we have Chinese actresses acting as Japanese geishas who have a remarkably good knowledge of English. Now, I do have some reservations about the films realism when it comes to language, but certainly one must always suspend disbelief in movieland.
Other than that, the acting is okay. But again, the fact that the majority of actors speak in heavily accented English does, I think, impede upon the effectiveness of their acting. It is certainly strange also to hear people speaking Japanese in the background while the geishas chit chat in English.
But the sets and props are very realistic, lush and beautiful to behold. No expense was spared, in this regard. That is, perhaps, the only part of the movie I like. (In fact the majority of Oscar nominations this movie has received falls in this area)
The story however was, in my judgement, not told very well (to add to the fact that it wasn't really good and only slighly interesting to begin with).
Another thing I'd like to note- the characters tell us that geishas do not sell their body. But they certainly do sell their virginity (I guess the both are not the same). The fact that a few sex scenes are thrown in doesn't help. Perhaps the producers do find and wish to show the inconsistency. I don't know, and I have not read Arthur Golden's book so I can't know for sure.
Regardless, Memoirs does have its entertaining and interesting bits- but not enough to change my perception that the movie does
not work.